Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Emma's avatar

Dr. Gay, I love your writing and have long relished the ability to take in your perspective on various topics through this newsletter and social media. I learn so much from you. I would like to invite a little more nuance to the Graham Platner conversation, if you'll humor me. I can only speak for myself, but as a Mainer, I did not delight in ranking Platner by any means, nor am I interested in lending any extra slack towards tolerating another shitty white man. But voting for Platner also felt like the (marginally) best option out of several very lousy options. Andrea LaFlamme couldn't collect enough signatures to get on the ballot, and her messaging was basically "vote for me because I'm the best candidate," while never attempting to connect with voters in the largest city in Maine (Portland). David Costello couldn't be bothered to connect with any of the immigrant communities in Maine. Janet Mills is an establishment Dem, through and through -- to quote you, the very definition of "Nothing ever changes in politics, not really." Susan Collins is absolutely evil in my opinion. Platner has made a LOT of unforced errors. I do not forgive him for his nazi tattoo; I do not look kindly upon his reddit posts. But I do see someone who, when ICE activity surged here in January, actually showed up for our immigrant neighbors in meaningful ways, when no other candidate has done so at all. It might all be a stunt, and I do not feel particularly trustful of this man, but I also believe he is the only candidate who stands a chance at beating Collins and I don't think he can be any more evil than she is.

Finally, I will add that Shay Stewart-Bouley is an organizer and writer living in Maine who has written a lot about this race and Platner in particular (https://blackgirlinmaine.com/) and I have found her insights and perspectives incredibly helpful in making some more sense of this messy senate race, and I recommend anyone to read her various pieces on the subject if you haven't already.

No posts

Ready for more?